Belenky, M.F., Clinchy, B.M., Goldberger, N.R., & Tarule, J.M. (1986).
Women's ways of knowing: the development of self, voice, and mind. New
York: Basic Books. Reviewed by Charlotte Knauke
The authors explore the ways women learn and how that differs from the
dominant thought about learning and knowing in our culture. The progression of
knowing and
learning that they found in women they interviewed encompasses four
basic steps:
Received knowledge
These women look outside themselves and their friends for
guidance, answers to questions, for the "right" way to do things. An
example given in
the book was about a woman who did not know how to take care of her
children. She depended on the staff at the children's health center to do
things
for her and to tell her the "right" way to take care of her children.
Subjective knowledge
At this step, a woman encounters her inner voice and begins to
listen and act on what she hears inside her. She moves from being passive
to action
based on her own inside knowledge instead of depending on people
outside herself. The
authors told a story of a woman who was reared
in a home that told the females that they are to be silent and serve the
men. She
married a man that continued this way of thinking . She came to a point
in her life where
she realized that she was not dumb and a know-nothing. She began to
tune in to her inner self to decide what was right for her.
Procedural knowledge
Not all women move onto this step. In this step, the woman move
into the area of reconciling the difference between her inner voice and the outside
authorities.
The woman begins to understand the "authorities" viewpoints instead of
rejecting these views. This type of knowledge is connected knowledge because it
is founded on understanding and relationships.
Separate knowledge is the knowledge gained from "considering others as it
wishes
to be considered". These women are oriented toward impersonal rules,
such as "What standards are being used to evaluate this paper? What techniques
shall I use to write it?"
The women at this step spoke from either the separate knowing voice or
the connected knowing voice. They might move from one to the other. But the two
voices were separate and distinct.
Constructed knowledge
It was at this step that the women in the study began to integrate the
two voices
of connected knowing and separate knowing. She begins to "find a place
for reason and tuition and the expertise of others." This woman begins the task
of integrating "knowledge they felt intuitively was personally important with
the knowledge they had learned from others". They appreciate the "experts" but
decide for
themselves the validity that knowledge for them. Becoming aware of the
workings of their mind is vital to these women.
The authors felt that understanding how women learn best would usher in a
new design for educating women - a design that is both more communal and less
adversarial with the women fully engaged with the material. The professor would
guide and
challenge the student without reducing her self-esteem. Ideas, thoughts,
and experiential knowledge would flow throughout the discussion, with each
student being listened to on her own terms.
A woman who wants to more fully understand the impact of our culture on
her learning and knowing would benefit from the material in this book to better
understand
her journey. A man who is willing to question and ponder his views of
the world and is willing to "step into another's shoes" would encounter the
struggle and
passage of the women in his world, and may yield some insights into his
own ways of knowing.

Back to Annotated Bibliographies.